[knah]

I realize wooster and orrville would be split up...but for travel, school size, and competition, this would be great.

Triway
West Holmes
Orrville
Manchester
Canal Fulton Northwest
Fairless
Dover
New Philly

We could add a couple of schools and make it a big school/small school or North/South as well.

12 schools would also work if we added some of the following:
Tuslaw, Indian Valley, Tusky Valley, Wooster, Loudonville, Coshocton, Timken

[shstiger73]

Fairless would have a hard time competing in football. Would replace with Wooster, Canton South, or Canton Central Catholic.

[440xng]

This is essentially the All-Ohio League minus Coventry but adding the historical rivalry in Tuscarawas County. Now we need a new moniker since "AOL" is trademarked.
Wooster would still play Orrville the final weekend.